Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kirsten Bell's avatar

I always feel that giving books as Christmas presents, like giving art, is something of a minefield, because tastes in books are so personal. Therefore, if you get it wrong, you will mortally offend your gift-ee, who will take it as confirmation that you don't really know them at all. (I’m fairly confident that friendships have been broken over poorly considered books given as gifts.) However, as a social anthropologist, I have some other classic offerings to add to your 'Introduction to Anthropology' collection, for those brave enough to give anthropology books as gifts.

1) In the interests of maintaining Anglo-Franco balance, you can’t possibly mention Levi-Strauss without also mentioning his most significant British counterpart, Mary Douglas, who was strongly influenced by his work but took it in new directions! See especially 'Purity and Danger' and 'Natural Symbols'.

2) Nigel Barley's 'An Innocent Anthropologist: Notes From a Mud Hut' – a hilarious account of his fieldwork in Cameroon which also takes some well-placed digs at the pretensions of anthropology as a discipline.

3) Marvin Harris's 'Cows, Pigs, Wars and Witches: Riddles of Culture' – I’m not a cultural materialist myself, but he has an interesting and readable perspective on a wide array of topics from food taboos to the medieval witch hunts.

4) Peter Worsley's 'The Trumpet Shall Sound '– a fascinating study of cargo cults in Melanesia.

Also, if you decide to develop a category of 'recent but deeply unfashionable anthropology books' or 'popular anthropology books written by actual anthropologists' (although they're basically synonymous at this point) then may I be so bold as to nominate my own recent book: 'Silent but Deadly: The Underlying Cultural Patterns of Everyday Behaviour'.

Expand full comment
Keith's avatar

Very useful Christmas book list, if only for myself! And good that you included a fiction book. I often start non-fiction books with lots of enthusiasm but rarely finish them. It seems the element of suspense is essential for me to keep reading. This is why Substack posts or articles, with their limited length, are ideal. Any longer and I might give up.

The problem with choosing a novel about pre-history or early history is that at the back of my mind I'm thinking, 'Would an expert in this field dismiss this as absolute trash?' From your recommendation I can assume that it's not a total fantasy and that although the events in the book didn't happen, there's no logical reason why they couldn't have.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts