Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Copper Axe | MusaeumScythia's avatar

Unfortunately all of their claims relied on faulty f-stats interpretations. The Takarkori genomes model perfectly as a mixture between the Iberomaurusians and a sub-saharan population intermediate between West African Niger-Congo and Nilotic populations. Using Yoruba and Dinka as a references gets you about 1/3 for each component. An interesting part is that various Saharan speaking populations, or the isolated Laal population, both somewhat in proximity to the Takarkori site, perfectly capture this intermediate position but this is more likely to be superficial similarity than a direct link in my opinion. The samples also seem to lack direct ancestry from Natufian or Levant PPNB-derived populations, which fits with their mtdna N lineage not sharing any recent connections with extant N haplogroups.

The material culture of Takarkori fits perfectly as a population from the chain of wavy line pottery hunter-fishers found across the Sahara adopting pastoralism, similar to what we see in central Sudan in the archaeological record (Leiterband complex near Wadi Howar for ex). This pottery-fisher complex has been associated with Nilo-Saharan languages by researchers such as Roger Blench. Aside from the pottery connection between dotted/wavy line and Nilo-Saharan groups, the matrilineal burial custom also seems in line with this. Then we have the element of physical anthropology perfectly aligning too, as the TKK physical remains were quite similar to those found in other Saharan sites.

The problem highlights how this field suffers from geneticists completely lacking any archaeological or anthropological context for the periods they are investigating, and also highlights the importance of independent analyses in DNA. Unfortunately it is not the case in this field that you can just assume that a published article has a correct analysis.

Expand full comment
Raphael's avatar

I watched a video on Robert Sepher YouTube channel where he showed a video presentation of geneticist showing the migration of populations of The world dating hundred to thousand years that there’s never been any out of out of Africa genetics in the white population. white slaves into Africa. But there’s never African genetics found in Europe or in the Americas or Asia

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts